Eng Lit

This site is a place for students to chat about issues related to the study of English Literature.

Tuesday, November 23, 2004

Justifying the Ways of God to Man

In Paradise Lost, Milton attempts to justify the ways of God to man. One of the arguments he must have considered runs as follows

  1. God is perfectly good
  2. God is omnipotent
  3. Evil exists

ergo: God does not exist

(in logic, if it can be shown that any assertion is incorrect or incompatible with any of the other assertions upon which an argument is based, the conclusion must also be false).

In the argument above, if God is all-powerful, but does not choose to get rid of evil, then he cannot be perfectly good; if God is perfectly good, but he is not able to rid the world of evil, he is not omnipotent. In either case, philosophers have argued, God--at least an omnipotent, perfectly loving one--is not compatible with the assertion that evil exists.

What do you think? How well does Milton do in dealing with this argument in Paradise Lost?

Sunday, November 21, 2004

Alas, Poor Hooded Thunder

The Gnome shattered in English the other day. I laughed. The winning vote was for the name "Hooded Thunder." Perhaps that can be emblazoned on his ceramic headstone.

Okay, Okay, Mary Shelley's Ghost Story, vol. 3

I remember the curve.

Help Chris Clark (again) for Bonus Marks

Any ideas for a paper?
I was considering writing about Milton's attempt to reveal to the
reader what the Protestant revolution, which they have evidently
betrayed, is all about?
I need something that could blow my prof away though. She's a tough
cookie, I need a decent starting point. I'm sure you've written some
mind-blowing papers.
Don't help me other than a topic idea :) xoxo
What's new in PG? Dec 21 - 27th is PG time for me. Then 30th is NYC
time. Party time!
Chris Clark

This is Chris's (pathetic) original post. Post your insightful essay topics for him. If they are actually college-grade, I will give you bonus marks for Literature 12. This means you may have to do some research. Alternatively, you could simply ignore my posting (as usual).

MC

Friday, November 12, 2004

Renaissance Feast (Costumes and Comments)

http://www.knowledgehound.com/topics/renaissa.htm

This site has lots of cheapo costume ideas, et cetera.